Starters via @MLBONFOX, Pitchers and reserves via CBS
Ok, lot to digest here. For the first time in a while I’m thinking the voters (aka you clowns) did a pretty good job this year, picking the right players and not just their hometown guys (looking at you, Kansas City). Starting with the AL starters, it’s obviously great to see some Red Sox guys back in there but these 4 EARNED it. They’ve all had tremendous years and deserve every bit of this. Add those four to Wright and Kimbrel in as pitchers, and Pedey (who’s my favorite in the Final Vote, which I’ll get to) and that’s a possibility for 7 Boston guys at the Midsummer Classic. Not bad.
The rest of the AL starting lineup is pretty standard, although I am a bit surprised at Perez being able to win the entire vote. Never underestimate people in the Midwest once the harvest is done, they’ve got Internet and they kinda know how to use it. The reserves for the AL don’t really jump out at all, and besides the omission of Rick Porcello the AL staff seems pretty solid, although adding Marco Estrada while two of his teammates (Marcus Stroman and Aaron Sanchez) have been arguably better to this point in the season is a bit of a head scratcher. But all in all, not a lot of major snubs.
On the NL side, the north side of Chicago absolutely rules the infield as Rizzo, Zobrist (who beat Daniel Murphy by EIGHTY-EIGHT votes), Russell, and Bryant take up the starting infield. That’ll be the smoothest pregame infield in All-Star Game history, huh? Teammate Dexter Fowler joins them in the outfield alongside Cespedes and Harper, and Buster Posey gets the nod behind the dish. Wil Meyers sneaks in as a reserve and locks up the title for loudest pregame announcement ovation due to being the only Padre in the game, and it’s good to see young guys like Arenado and Seager getting the recognition they’ve earned. As far as arms, no qualms from me. You’ve gotta have the Kershaws, Bumgarners, Arrietas, etc. of the world, and that middle relief set of Familia, Jansen, and Melancon will make it tough for the AL to score late in the game.
And now, for the final vote. First, the AL.
Like I said, Pedey is my favorite here not just because he deserves it the most (7th in the AL with 103 hits) but because he’s just the most popular. Won a Rookie of the Year, won an MVP, won a couple World Series, and he’s a gritty little guy people love to root for. Kinsler started slow but has turned on the jets as of late and could very well give this title a run, as could Houston’s young stud George Springer, who’s tied for 7th in the AL in homers. Saunders and Longoria are stretches in my opinion, but who knows when crazy ass baseball fans get voting.
The NL:
To me this race is a little more wide open. Marte is one of the most feared hitters in the NL but he’s missed some time with a nagging foot injury and his numbers aren’t what they could be. Trevor Story was the story of April (sorry) belting homers seemingly every game for the first few weeks of his career, but has cooled off as of late and now leads the NL with 108 strikeouts. Lamb is a newcomer in Arizona with a lot of pop but not enough of a fan base to make all that much noise here, Braun is a former juicer so it’s always hard to tell, but his .322 average speaks for itself, and Brandon Belt is, in my opinion, one of the most underrated players in baseball today, a solid defensive first basemen with a good bat who has helped the Giants win their last 2 championships. It’s anybody’s race in the NL, but due to fan base I’m gonna go with Belt.
As far as the game, it’s impossible to really predict but I’m going with the AL because that offense just seems unstoppable, and Kershaw’s back not allowing him to play could hurt the NL as far as needing to get outs early while the starting lineup is still hitting. If Papi goes yard he’ll get the MVP because we’re all soft, but if he doesn’t I think a reserve like Josh Donaldson or Francisco Lindor will make some noise and walk away with ASG MVP.
The MLB All-Star Game will be played Tuesday, July 12th at 8:00 EST in San Diego, CA.